·4 min read
Cedar vs. Pine Siding: Which Is Right for Your Home?
By Rustic Lumber Co.

It's one of the questions we hear most at the yard: should I go with cedar or pine siding?
Here's the short answer. Cedar costs more up front but holds up better with less upkeep. Pine saves money and gives you that classic rustic look, as long as you protect it well.
Both are great choices. The right one depends on your budget, your home, and how much sun and snow your walls take. Here's what to think about.
Our Weather Is Tough on Siding
If you live in Utah, Idaho, or Colorado, your siding works hard. The sun is stronger up here. The air is dry. And winter brings snow that melts in the afternoon and freezes again at night.
All of that makes wood shrink, swell, and fade faster than it would in milder places. So the species you pick, and the finish you put on it, really matter.
Why People Love Cedar Siding
Cedar is the classic choice for mountain homes, and for good reason.
It fights rot and bugs on its own. Cedar has natural oils that help it resist decay.
It stays straight. Cedar is less likely to warp or cup, even in our dry air.
It's light and easy to work with. That can mean a faster install.
It looks amazing. The warm color and fine grain are hard to beat.
It soaks up stain evenly. So your finish looks better and lasts longer.
The catch? Cedar costs more. But many homeowners find it pays off over time with less maintenance.
Cedar is a great fit for: custom homes, cabins, soffits, and walls that get a lot of sun.
Why People Choose Pine Siding
Pine is a smart pick when you want great looks without the higher price tag.
It's easier on the budget. Especially on bigger projects, barns, and shops.
It has that rustic charm. Visible knots give it a classic cabin and farmhouse feel.
It comes in lots of styles. Tongue and groove, shiplap, channel, and board and batten.
It looks great pre-finished. A factory stain gives it strong protection from day one.
The catch? Pine doesn't fight rot as well as cedar, so a good finish and regular upkeep are a must.
Pine is a great fit for: budget builds, barns, garages, outbuildings, and interior accent walls.
The Secret Most People Miss: The Finish
Here's something we tell every customer. Bare wood, cedar or pine, will fade and gray fast in our sun. The finish is what protects it.
That's why we created pre-finished products like our Jasperwood line. The stain goes on in a controlled setting, on every side and edge, before it ever reaches your job site. You get better coverage, more even color, and less work on site.
You can pick your color from our collections, like the earthy Uinta Collection or the rich Sawtooth Collection, and the protection comes built in.
So, Which Should You Pick?
Ask yourself these quick questions:
What's my budget? Tight budget, lean toward pine. Want it to last with less upkeep, lean toward cedar.
How much sun does the wall get? South and west walls take a beating. Cedar or pre-finished wood is the safer bet there.
What look do I want? Clean and refined points to cedar. Knotty and rustic points to pine.
Do I have HOA or fire-zone rules? Check before you order.
A lot of our customers use both: cedar on the front of the house and the sunny sides, pine on the shop or an inside accent wall.
Talk to a Wood Expert Before You Buy
At Rustic Lumber, we work directly with the mills, so you get quality cedar and pine siding at wholesale prices. We've been helping builders and homeowners across Utah, Idaho, and Colorado since 2008.
Not sure what's right for your project? Give us a call. We're happy to help.
Utah: 801.882.2021
Idaho: 208.656.3036
Colorado: 720.722.4700
Or check out our price list and see our recent projects.
Common Questions
- Is cedar siding worth the extra money? For most homes here, yes. It lasts longer and needs less upkeep, which can make up for the higher price over time.
- How long does pine siding last? With a good finish and regular care, pine siding can last for decades.
- Can I use pine siding outside in Utah or Colorado? Yes. Just make sure it's finished on all sides and installed with good drainage and space off the ground.
- What does STK cedar mean? STK stands for "select tight knot." It has small, tight knots for a natural but clean look.
- Do you sell pre-finished siding? Yes. Our Jasperwood products and color collections come pre-finished and ready to install.